Lately I have tried to be very positive on my blog as positive posts seem to generate more traffic. However… I saw this while tweaking my days meals and had to post about it.
IT’S THE COOKIE DIET! YAY! We’re saved! No more not eating cookies on our diet. So, either they taste terrible or there is a catch. That said I went on a hunt for the nutrition information. Here is what I found:
.: Click Picture For Full-Size :.
Now, if you don’t know how to read one of those tags, and a large portion of the population does not, you may think: “Oooh! Shiny! They have testimonials and the box of cookies is $19.99!! So it must work!” That’s where you’d be wrong.
These cookies have roughly the same nutrition information as a Nabisco Cookies which… by the way are lots cheaper! I mean you’re talking like $3.99 per package versus $19.99. Just so you don’t think I’m lying to you, here is the nutrition info for a Nabisco cookie:
.: Click Picture For Full-Size :.
So, some things to note here. The cookies are comparable, however there are some differences.
- The Nabisco cookie is a smaller serving, so if you were to eat 40 grams you’re looking at 28 more calories.
- The Hollywood Diet Cookies have 4.4 grams fewer fat, and only 1g of Saturated Fat compared to the 4.45g in the Nabisco cookie.
- The Nabisco Cookie has more carbohydrates ( carbs ). 26 grams compared to the 24 grams in the Hollywood Diet Cookies.
- The Hollywood Diet Cookies has 5 grams of protein compared to the 1.48 gram in the Nabisco Cookie.
- The Hollywood Diet Cookies have more Vitamin A, C, Calcium, Iron and fiber ( you shouldn’t get your fiber from a cookie anyway ) than the Nabisco Cookie.
I am sure that there other differences, however those are what I would consider “primary”. Considering the price point of the Hollywood Diet cookies those differences are not vast enough to go with their product.
So what does all that mean? What are carbs, fat, and protein? Well… carbs, fat, and protein are also known as Macro-nutrients. They are the building blocks of food, so when you put them all together you get the calories in a food. The way this works is this:
What does it all mean?
1 Gram of Protein = 4 Calories
1 Gram of Carbohydrates = 4 Calories
1 Gram of Fat = 9 CaloriesProtein rebuilds muscle, replaces tissue, etc. It is broken down by the body and used to build whatever tissue is needed to repair, grow… to live. It can also provide energy, long explanation there.
Carbohydrates provide energy. They are what your muscles will eventually use as fuel. Carbs are broken down into Glycogen and consumed by muscles. If you eat too many and your body cannot use them the liver turns those carbs into fat and stores them in your as… body.
Fat is very high in energy and thus packs a whoping 9 calories per gram. That is why it is often seen as “bad”. There are many types of fat, some are good, some are bad, some can be bad if they are acquired the wrong way. We won’t get into that. Saturated fat is the stuff that clogs your veins… well if you have too much. It’s actually also used for hormone generation, but that’s beside the point. /mini_rant
Some Simple Math
The Hollywood Diet Cookies have 4.5 grams of fat, 24 grams of carbs and 5 grams of protein. So let’s do the math:
4.5 x 9 = 40.5 calories
24 x 4 = 96.0 calories
5 x 4 = 20.0 calories
———————–
Total = 156.5 calories ( looks like they rounded down lawl )
So the macro-nutrient split is roughly similar between the two cookies and the Nabisco cookie is WAY cheaper. So why do these folks claim that their diet works? Well… I went on to read this little tidbit:
“We all know that to lose weight we have to restrict calories, but that is easier said than done. When hunger strikes, diets fail. The Hollywood Cookie Diet works by satisfying your hunger and your sweet tooth. Simply eat up to four cookies a day, replacing breakfast and lunch, and eat a sensible dinner. Eat a cookie for breakfast, mid-morning snack, lunch and mid-afternoon snack. The Hollywood Cookie Diet works because it is a low calorie diet based on caloric restriction by meal replacement and portion control.”
So what you are supposed to do is:
- Eat a cookie for breakfast, starve and be dangerously under nourished until lunch.
- Eat another cookie for lunch and continue to be miserable.
- When 3:00 strikes and you’re about to pass out because you haven’t eaten yet… HAVE ANOTHER COOKIE !!! Whee! Guess what!? You still have not eaten.
- Finally when you get home… “eat a sensible dinner”. Let’s be realistic… if you have not eaten anything and it’s 6:00 in the afternoon you are going to devour a pizza, or slay a box of doughnuts. ( I wonder if there is a doughnut diet!? )
So I’m being a negative ninny! Sure, but this is absolute non-sense… If you want to achieve the same results as this diet buy the Nabisco cookies and give it a shot. If you can eat just 4 cookies and a “sensible” dinner for more than 3 days ( if you try this I am not to be held liable for any consequences! IT IS A BAD IDEA !! ) and not scarf down a pizza or some huge meal or faint… My hat is off to you!
The other choice you have is to throw 2 scoops of Vanilla Whey Protein Powder into home made cookie bater. It will raise the protein content considerably and the home made recipe is probably healthier.
Moral of the story?
There is no way around it. Good old fashioned healthy eating every few hours, 5 or 6 meals per day, with a good macro split and portion control with a nice helping of exercise is the only thing that works. It is way easier to eat 5 or 6 times per day and eat healthy meals. If done right you won’t be hungry at all. I usually eat at my BMR and exercise vigorously to lose weight. Then when I want to gain I eat at about 1.5 times the BMR , lift more and reduce the cardio ( not cut it out… reduce it ). By the way… that’s cheaper too!
Here are some good resources for learning more about macro nutrients, nutrition and exercise:
- This is where I started out. John Stone Fitness
Poke around the forum you’ll find explanations of all the macronutrients, BMR, exercise routines, etc.- This Thread has some great links: BEGINNERS/NEW MEMBERS
These two guides on that thread are exactly where I started:
- Gravityhomer’s fat loss guide (by gravityhomer)
- My guide to nutrition for weight loss (by marcus)
- I blogged about a site I found that had great full body workouts that are about 15 minutes long. Check it out.
Update:
Noticed that the serving size was actually part of the 1 cookie and the 27 vs. 40g makes a difference so I updated the differences section.
Good luck!


